Skip to content
Link copied to clipboard
Link copied to clipboard

A PPA employee crashed into an out-of-towner’s parked car in January. She’s been stuck in Philly since.

“Vehicle involved in accident call PPA,” read one of the notes left on Beanca Gordner's car, with a number said to belong to a “manager.”

Beanca Gordner, on way to Columbia County, PA., stopped to visit son in Philadelphia when she claims her car was hit by Philadelphia Parking Authority vehicle. She is holding a photograph of her vehicle after it was pushed onto the sidewalk behind her. Photograph taken Wednesday morning April 2, 2025 along Bainbridge just east of S. Broad Street.
Beanca Gordner, on way to Columbia County, PA., stopped to visit son in Philadelphia when she claims her car was hit by Philadelphia Parking Authority vehicle. She is holding a photograph of her vehicle after it was pushed onto the sidewalk behind her. Photograph taken Wednesday morning April 2, 2025 along Bainbridge just east of S. Broad Street.Read moreAlejandro A. Alvarez / Staff Photographer

Beanca Gordner, 57, was passing through South Philadelphia, visiting her son who’d just had a birthday, when a Philadelphia Parking Authority employee crashed into her parked car in late January, pushing it halfway onto the sidewalk.

The only clues left for her were two notes on the windshield of her white 2014 Chevy Cruze.

“Vehicle involved in accident call PPA,” read one of the notes, with a number said to belong to a “manager.” The other slip of paper listed her police report number, which she would later learn got her name and some of her vehicle information, including registration, wrong.

“I had to do my own investigation to try and find out what happened to my vehicle,” Gordner said.

Gordner, who was headed from Florida to Berwick, Pa., to start her new juicing business, is now at odds with the PPA over what is “fair” after what appears to have been a freak accident.

Though the PPA said it is limited in what it can say publicly regarding a personnel matter, Gordner feels she is entitled to all the details related to the accident. All she knows is based on the one-paragraph summary of the incident in the police report, which says the PPA employee’s “clipboard got caught in between the steering wheel,” causing the driver to lose control as she drove eastbound on Bainbridge Street.

 

Adding to Gordner’s frustrations, she and the PPA disagree over what is owed to her and how long it has taken to reimburse her. Gordner asked the authority for $15,000 for her troubles. The ask was immediately rejected by the PPA, she said.

The PPA would not cover a rental car, and Gordner thinks the PPA should reimburse her for towing and storage — her car remains in a lot after the crash. The PPA alleges that it was waiting on Gordner to submit the necessary documents and that some of her demands, including reimbursement for lost wages and $3,600 for emotional distress, were unreasonable.

“Because the vehicle will not be repaired, the parking authority agreed to pay Ms. Gordner nearly three times the blue book value of her car to address the issue she raised,” PPA spokesperson Martin O’Rourke said in prepared remarks. “While Ms. Gordner has indicated a desire to go to the press or sue the PPA, the parking authority remains willing to resolve this matter amicably.”

Gordner began talking with a PPA representative on Jan. 30, though she said the number left on her windshield was the wrong one and led to a disconnected line. According to the authority, she was asked to provide a driver’s license, the declaration page of her insurance, a copy of her registration, and an itemized estimate to repair the damage. The latter had to come from a licensed auto mechanic or repair/auto body shop. O’Rourke said the PPA did not receive the last of the documents until March 14 — after a reminder letter was sent out to Gordner in late February.

From Gordner’s perspective, the instructions that were first provided over the phone were not clear, and she feels the PPA should have handled getting the estimate for the repairs. She said she had difficulty finding someone that would go to the lot where her car had been towed.

She also feels like her request is a reasonable one. Her car is her prized possession, she explained. Despite having close to 180,000 miles, it was a reliable mode of transportation. So much so that when Gordner had enough of hurricane season in Florida and made the move back home to Columbia County, Pa., she loaded her Chevy onto a car hauler to save on miles. Her plan was to begin her juicing business once she was in Northeastern Pennsylvania, but she has remained in Philly with her son as she sorts out her reimbursement.

On Tuesday, the PPA sent Gordner a letter saying that now that it had all the required documentation, it could process her claim. The authority offered her just over $5,800.

Gordner is disappointed and considering legal action.

“I’m just not sure yet which way I’m going,” she said Wednesday.